Companies We Represent


We have choices for you.. lots of choices

Independent insurance agents like Carter's Insurance Agency, give customers choice and options when it comes to their insurance needs.

A captive agent only sells for one company. Captive agents can't give you the options we can. We sell for a variety of companies.

Simply put, we offer you more choice and independent advice.

Carter's Insurance Agency selects companies that offer value, quality coverage and competitive prices. Here is a showcase of our most popular companies. You can click the "Company Details" on each carrier, to access 24 hour claim service phone numbers and carrier portal login access for these popular companies.

Our Preferred Carriers

Company Details

Click Here

Hochheim Prairie Farm Mutual

24 Hour Claims

Access Your Account

Encompass Insurance Company

24 Hour Claims

Access Your Account

Mercury Insurance Company

24 Hour Claims

Access Your Account

Progressive Insurance Company

24 Hour Claims

Access Your Account

Travelers Insurance Company

24 Hour Claims

Access Your Account

Allstate Insurance Company

24 Hour Claims

Access Your Account

Foremost Insurance Company